• Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • RSS
  • Sign In
  • My Account
High-Profile MonthlyNew England Facilities Development News
  • All News
      • Up Front
      • Groundbreaking
      • Topping Off
      • Ribbon Cutting
      • View All Up Front Stories
      • stock-educationRogers High School Breaks Ground
      • Special Features
      • Contributor
      • Green
      • J.E.D.I.
      • Mechanical / Electrical / Plumbing (MEP)
      • Vision
      • Women In Construction
      • Regions
      • Connecticut
      • Northern New England
      • Popular Sectors
      • Cannabis
      • Corporate
      • Education
      • Healthcare
      • Interiors
      • Landscape/Civil
      • Life Science
      • Multi Residential
      • Restoration/Renovation
      • Retail/Hospitality
      • Senior/Assisted Living
      • Technology & Innovation
      • Other News
      • Awards
      • Community
      • COVID-19
      • Mixed-use
      • Municipal
      • National/International
      • Organizations and Events
      • People
      • Philanthropy
      • Products and Services
      • Real Estate
      • Training and Recruitment
  • Subscribe
  • Membership
  • Next Issue
  • Archive
  • Advertise
  • Podcast
  • Events
    • Industry Events
    • A/E/C Associations
High-Profile Monthly
  • All News
      • Up Front
      • Groundbreaking
      • Topping Off
      • Ribbon Cutting
      • View All Up Front Stories
      • stock-educationRogers High School Breaks Ground
      • Special Features
      • Contributor
      • Green
      • J.E.D.I.
      • Mechanical / Electrical / Plumbing (MEP)
      • Vision
      • Women In Construction
      • Regions
      • Connecticut
      • Northern New England
      • Popular Sectors
      • Cannabis
      • Corporate
      • Education
      • Healthcare
      • Interiors
      • Landscape/Civil
      • Life Science
      • Multi Residential
      • Restoration/Renovation
      • Retail/Hospitality
      • Senior/Assisted Living
      • Technology & Innovation
      • Other News
      • Awards
      • Community
      • COVID-19
      • Mixed-use
      • Municipal
      • National/International
      • Organizations and Events
      • People
      • Philanthropy
      • Products and Services
      • Real Estate
      • Training and Recruitment
  • Subscribe
  • Membership
  • Next Issue
  • Archive
  • Advertise
  • Podcast
  • Events
    • Industry Events
    • A/E/C Associations
Contributor • Featured

Recent Guidance for Paragraph E Vendors

July 23, 2020

 by Emanuel Bardanis

A recent advisory opinion from the Massachusetts attorney general provides important guidance for listing so-called “Paragraph E” vendors – i.e., specialized sub-subcontractors – on trade bid forms for jobs bid under M.G.L. c. 149A.  In a nutshell, the opinion states that trade bidders may make such listings even where the awarding authority has not specifically requested them. Indeed, failing to do so could result in a possible challenge to a successful low trade bid. 

“Paragraph E” listings were created as part of the traditional c. 149 approach to public bidding.  Because certain work is almost always sub-subcontracted out – e.g., temperature controls work within the HVAC trade – the bid laws had to allow such delegation, albeit with certain limits.  First, the awarding authority must make clear in the bid documents what work may be sub-subcontracted and even then, it can only do so if that work is: (1) customarily sub-subcontracted within the trade and (2) worth more than $25,000.  If these criteria are met, the sub-bidder must list who will perform this work, and at what price, on Paragraph E of the statutory bid form contained in M.G.L. c. 149, § 44F.  A sub-bidder may also list itself if it customarily performs such work, in which case it need not state a price.

Many trade bidders assumed c. 149A worked the same way, as the bid process is similar.  There are key differences, however.  First, as the advisory opinion notes, there is no statutory bid form in M.G.L c. 149A, § 8, which governs trade bidding.  Hence, unlike under c. 149, § 44F, trade bid forms need not include language restricting bidders to listing only those sub-subcontractors “for which the provisions of the section of the specifications for this sub-trade require a listing.”  Rather, c. 149A, § 8 requires “certification that the trade contractor will perform the complete trade work with employees on his own payroll, except for work customarily performed by sub-trade subcontractors within the trade; and the names of all sub-trade subcontractors to be used if awarded the trade contract and each sub-trade contract sum [emphasis added].”   

Hence, the attorney general concluded that listing a sub-subcontractor on a c. 149A trade bid form, although the specifications do not call for such a listing, does not necessarily require rejection on grounds it is an “addition not called for.”  Of course, if the awarding authority’s trade bid form contains the traditional c. 149 “Paragraph E” language quoted above, the result could be different (And even then, the awarding authority may be able to waive the error).  But short of that – or unless the Legislature rewrites c. 149A, § 8 – trade bidders on c. 149A job must list all sub-subcontractors they intend to use, as long as the work is “customarily performed by sub-trade subcontractors within the trade.”  If you are unsure as to whether to make such a listing on a c. 149A job, the safest course would be to make a pre-bid inquiry asking the awarding authority to confirm the listing is appropriate. 

Emanuel Bardanis

Emanuel Bardanis is a partner at  Corwin & Corwin LLP.

advisoryopinion AttorneyGeneral Aug'20 contributor featured guidance HPNews massachusetts ParagraphE tradebidders
    FacebookTwitterLinkedInEmail

You may also like

Contributor • Featured

Exterior Elements: Making the Most...

June 29, 2022
Contributor • Featured • Life Science

The Science of Mitigating Supply...

June 28, 2022
Contributor

Cybersecurity for AEC Firms

June 28, 2022
Contributor • Featured • Life Science

Design and Construction...

June 27, 2022
Contributor • Featured

The Contractor’s Consent to...

June 24, 2022
Contributor • Featured • Life Science

Surfing The Life Science...

June 9, 2022
Contributor • Featured • Healthcare

Four Construction Considerations...

June 3, 2022
Contributor • Featured • Healthcare

Restoring Trust through Dignified...

May 26, 2022

View the June 2022 issue!

Read HP’s 2022 MEP issue!

Read the WIC 2022 Supplement!

Check out the 2021 Annual Green Supplement!

Read our annual supplements!

  • Green2021.png
  • WIC2022.png
  • MEP2022.png
  • Vision-2019.png

HIGH-PROFILE MONTHLY
615 School St.
Pembroke, MA  02359
Phone: 781 294 4530
Fax:  781 293 5821
info@high-profile.com

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • My Account

Stay Informed

Sign up for Fast Facts Friday, our weekly e-newsletter, and stay up-to-date with the latest industry news!

Sign up
Subscribe to High-Profile Monthly to receive an email notice of each new article!
Loading

Copyright © 2022 High-Profile Monthly.

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • RSS
  • Sign In
  • My Account