• Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • RSS
  • Sign In
  • My Account
High-Profile MonthlyNew England Facilities Development News
  • All News
      • Up Front
      • Groundbreaking
      • Topping Off
      • Ribbon Cutting
      • View All Up Front Stories
      • BHCC 2Community College Breaks Ground on Student Success Center
      • Special Features
      • Contributor
      • Green
      • J.E.D.I.
      • Mechanical / Electrical / Plumbing (MEP)
      • Vision
      • Women In Construction
      • Regions
      • Connecticut
      • Northern New England
      • Popular Sectors
      • Cannabis
      • Corporate
      • Education
      • Healthcare
      • Interiors
      • Landscape/Civil
      • Life Science
      • Multi Residential
      • Restoration/Renovation
      • Retail/Hospitality
      • Senior/Assisted Living
      • Technology & Innovation
      • Other News
      • Awards
      • Community
      • COVID-19
      • Mixed-use
      • Municipal
      • National/International
      • Organizations and Events
      • People
      • Philanthropy
      • Products and Services
      • Real Estate
      • Training and Recruitment
  • Subscribe
  • Membership
  • Next Issue
  • Archive
  • Advertise
  • Podcast
  • Events
    • Industry Events
    • A/E/C Associations
High-Profile Monthly
  • All News
      • Up Front
      • Groundbreaking
      • Topping Off
      • Ribbon Cutting
      • View All Up Front Stories
      • BHCC 2Community College Breaks Ground on Student Success Center
      • Special Features
      • Contributor
      • Green
      • J.E.D.I.
      • Mechanical / Electrical / Plumbing (MEP)
      • Vision
      • Women In Construction
      • Regions
      • Connecticut
      • Northern New England
      • Popular Sectors
      • Cannabis
      • Corporate
      • Education
      • Healthcare
      • Interiors
      • Landscape/Civil
      • Life Science
      • Multi Residential
      • Restoration/Renovation
      • Retail/Hospitality
      • Senior/Assisted Living
      • Technology & Innovation
      • Other News
      • Awards
      • Community
      • COVID-19
      • Mixed-use
      • Municipal
      • National/International
      • Organizations and Events
      • People
      • Philanthropy
      • Products and Services
      • Real Estate
      • Training and Recruitment
  • Subscribe
  • Membership
  • Next Issue
  • Archive
  • Advertise
  • Podcast
  • Events
    • Industry Events
    • A/E/C Associations
Contributor

Third Party Beneficiary Claims And Construction Contracts

April 12, 2019

by Hugh J. Gorman III

The U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts recently issued a decision clarifying when a third party who derives a benefit from a construction contract may sue for breach of that contract. In ARCO Ingenieros, S.A. de C.V. vs. CDM Int’l Inc., D. Mass., No. CV 18-12348-PBS (Mar. 22, 2019) the court held that a third party who incidentally benefited from a construction contract could not sue for breach where nothing in the language of the contract nor the surrounding circumstances suggested that the parties intended any benefit to the third party.

The ARCO case arose after the defendant, CDM International Inc., entered into a Task Order with the United States Agency for International Development (“USAID”) to assess sites and create preliminary designs for construction projects aimed at rebuilding El Salvador after Tropical Storm Ida. The Task Order also required CDM to participate in the procurement process for design-build contractors, who would use CDM’s preliminary designs as starting points for the projects.

The plaintiff, ARCO, submitted bids on specific construction projects in El Salvador based on the preliminary designs, and relied on representations made by USAID and by CDM that these designs constituted at least thirty percent of the final designs for each project. ARCO alleged that CDM’s preliminary designs contained numerous defects and were in fact substantially less than thirty percent of the final designs. ARCO filed suit against CDM, and alleged specifically in its breach of contract claim that it was the intended beneficiary of the CDM Task Order with USAID and had suffered damages due to the allegedly deficient preliminary designs. CDM filed a motion to dismiss ARCO’s breach of contract claim.

The District Court granted the defendant’s motion to dismiss the breach of contract claim, holding that ARCO was not an intended third party beneficiary of the CDM Task Order with USAID.  The court noted that “a third party qualifies as an intended beneficiary only if the language and circumstances of the contract show that the parties to the contract clearly and definitely intended the beneficiary to benefit from the promised performance.” Regardless of the fact that ARCO incidentally benefited from CDM’s studies and preliminary designs, because nothing in the language of the Task Order, nor the facts alleged suggested that USAID and CDM intended any benefit to ARCO, ARCO could not recover under a breach of contract theory. 

The ARCO case is significant as it confirms the proposition that a party may not recover as a third party beneficiary under a construction contract absent a clear indication of intent to benefit that party by the actual parties to the agreement, and holds that under Massachusetts law, not all third parties who derive a benefit from a construction contract can sue for damages thereunder.

Thanks to Elizabeth Farrenkopf (Northeastern 3L) who contributed to the preparation of this alert.

Hugh Gorman

Hugh J. Gorman III is partner and chair of Prince Lobel’s Construction Law Group.

ARCO construction constructioncontracts constructionlaw designbuild
    FacebookTwitterLinkedInEmail

You may also like

Trends and Hot Topics

The Whole Building Design Guide to...

May 13, 2022
Corporate

Suffolk Hosts ‘Fireside...

May 13, 2022
Featured • Groundbreaking • Up Front

Community College Breaks Ground on...

May 12, 2022
People

AGC MA Welcomes Jones

May 11, 2022
Awards

Construction Management Firm...

May 9, 2022
Topping Off

Topping Off Held for Leominster...

May 9, 2022
Trends and Hot Topics

MCA Releases 2021 Report

May 6, 2022
Restoration/Renovation

Ellacoya State Park Renovation...

May 6, 2022

View the May 2022 issue!

Read HP’s 2022 MEP issue!

Read the WIC 2022 Supplement!

Check out the 2021 Annual Green Supplement!

Read our annual supplements!

  • Green2021.png
  • WIC2022.png
  • MEP2022.png
  • Vision-2019.png

HIGH-PROFILE MONTHLY
615 School St.
Pembroke, MA  02359
Phone: 781 294 4530
Fax:  781 293 5821
info@high-profile.com

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • My Account

Stay Informed

Sign up for Fast Facts Friday, our weekly e-newsletter, and stay up-to-date with the latest industry news!

Sign up
Subscribe to High-Profile Monthly to receive an email notice of each new article!
Loading

Copyright © 2022 High-Profile Monthly.

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • RSS
  • Sign In
  • My Account