• Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • RSS
  • Sign In
  • My Account
High-Profile MonthlyNew England Facilities Development News
  • All News
      • Up Front
      • Groundbreaking
      • Topping Off
      • Ribbon Cutting
      • View All Up Front Stories
      • PXL_20230309_153128404Ground Broken on $40M Production Facility in Connecticut
      • Special Features
      • Contributor
      • Green
      • J.E.D.I.
      • Mechanical / Electrical / Plumbing (MEP)
      • Vision
      • Women In Construction
      • Regions
      • Connecticut
      • Northern New England
      • Popular Sectors
      • Cannabis
      • Corporate
      • Education
      • Healthcare
      • Interiors
      • Landscape/Civil
      • Life Science
      • Multi Residential
      • Restoration/Renovation
      • Retail/Hospitality
      • Senior/Assisted Living
      • Technology & Innovation
      • Other News
      • Awards
      • Community
      • COVID-19
      • Mixed-use
      • Municipal
      • National/International
      • Organizations and Events
      • People
      • Philanthropy
      • Products and Services
      • Real Estate
      • Training and Recruitment
  • Subscribe
  • Membership
  • Next Issue
  • Archive
  • Advertise
  • Podcast
  • Events
    • Industry Events
    • A/E/C Associations
High-Profile Monthly
  • All News
      • Up Front
      • Groundbreaking
      • Topping Off
      • Ribbon Cutting
      • View All Up Front Stories
      • PXL_20230309_153128404Ground Broken on $40M Production Facility in Connecticut
      • Special Features
      • Contributor
      • Green
      • J.E.D.I.
      • Mechanical / Electrical / Plumbing (MEP)
      • Vision
      • Women In Construction
      • Regions
      • Connecticut
      • Northern New England
      • Popular Sectors
      • Cannabis
      • Corporate
      • Education
      • Healthcare
      • Interiors
      • Landscape/Civil
      • Life Science
      • Multi Residential
      • Restoration/Renovation
      • Retail/Hospitality
      • Senior/Assisted Living
      • Technology & Innovation
      • Other News
      • Awards
      • Community
      • COVID-19
      • Mixed-use
      • Municipal
      • National/International
      • Organizations and Events
      • People
      • Philanthropy
      • Products and Services
      • Real Estate
      • Training and Recruitment
  • Subscribe
  • Membership
  • Next Issue
  • Archive
  • Advertise
  • Podcast
  • Events
    • Industry Events
    • A/E/C Associations
Contributor

SJC Holds That Parties Cannot Contract Away Willful or Knowing Violations of Ch. 93A

April 6, 2022

by Michael P. Dickman

On January 24, the Supreme Judicial Court (SJC) struck down a contractual limitation of liability provision as void against public policy. In H1 Lincoln, Inc. v. South Washington Street, LLC, et al., the SJC held that contract waiver does not preclude multiple damages under the Massachusetts consumer protection statute (G.L. c. 93A) for willful or knowing misconduct.

G.L. c. 93A, § 11 governs business-to-business disputes. Section 11 authorizes a person engaged in trade or commerce to file an action for damages and equitable relief arising from unfair and deceptive acts. If a violation of c. 93A is willful or knowing, a claimant may be entitled to recover double or treble damages.

In the underlying dispute, Alfredo Dos Anjos, the principal of the defendant entities, breached a lease for the operation of an automotive dealership by H1 Lincoln. The lease contained a limitation of liability provision barring recovery for “speculative or consequential damages.” H1 Lincoln filed a lawsuit in Hampden Superior Court against the Dos Anjos entities for breach of G.L. c. 93A, § 11, among other claims. After a bench trial that focused on the 93A claims, a Superior Court judge found in favor of H1 Lincoln and awarded double damages arising from the Dos Anjos entities’ willful and knowing violations of their contractual obligations by breaching the dealership lease.  The Superior Court held that the 93A violations sounded in tort, rather than contract, so the contractual waiver did not apply. The Dos Anjos entities appealed the lower court’s ruling and multiple damages award, arguing that even if their conduct violated c. 93A, the lease waived H1 Lincoln’s right to recover “speculative or consequential damages” which would include statutory multiple damages.

The SJC rejected this argument, holding that the limitation of liability provision was unenforceable as a matter of law. The SJC reached its conclusion through different means than the Superior Court, disregarding the distinction between the claim “sounding” in tort, not contract. Instead, the high court emphasized the public policy behind c. 93A and the punitive impact of multiple damages awards. Upholding contract waivers in instances where a party commits knowing or willful misconduct “would do violence” to the punishment and deterrence goals of multiple damages awards.

Moving forward, it will be critical for commercial actors to not rely on blanket contractual damages waivers to protect themselves against significant c. 93A exposure. While contract documents govern the relationship between the parties, the SJC’s decision in H1 Lincoln is a reminder that Massachusetts public policy plays a significant role as well.

Michael P. Dickman

Michael P. Dickman, Esq. is an associate at Kenney & Sams.

HPNews May'22
    FacebookTwitterLinkedInEmail

You may also like

Contributor • Life Science • MEP

Developing a Quality Base Building...

March 23, 2023
Contributor • MEP

Sprinkler Design Challenges for...

March 22, 2023
Contributor • Education

Data and Demographics: Driving the...

March 8, 2023
Contributor • Education

2023 Update from SCUP North...

March 8, 2023
Contributor • Education

A Message from SCUP President...

March 8, 2023
Contributor • Education

Linking Mission-infused Campus...

March 2, 2023
Contributor • Education

Designing Equitable Experiences...

February 28, 2023
Contributor • Education

Academia Driving Deployment of...

February 28, 2023

View the March 2023 issue!

Read the WIC 2023 Supplement!

Read HP’s 25th Anniversary Issue now!

Check out the 2022 Annual Green Supplement!

Read HP’s 2022 MEP issue!

Read our annual supplements!

  • Green2022.png
  • WIC2023.png
  • MEP2022.png
  • Vision-2019.png

HIGH-PROFILE MONTHLY
615 School St.
Pembroke, MA  02359
Phone: 781 294 4530
Fax:  781 293 5821
info@high-profile.com

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • My Account

Stay Informed

Sign up for Fast Facts Friday, our weekly e-newsletter, and stay up-to-date with the latest industry news!

Sign up
Subscribe to High-Profile Monthly to receive an email notice of each new article!
Loading

Copyright © 2023 High-Profile Monthly.

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • RSS
  • Sign In
  • My Account